Stefanski’s Stubborn Play-Calling Costs Browns Against Giants: What Does It Mean for the Team?

The Cleveland Browns' 21-15 loss to the New York Giants on Sunday has reignited concerns over head coach Kevin Stefanski’s rigid play-calling, raising questions about his ability to adapt mid-game and what it could mean for the team's future success.

CLEVELAND, OH - The Cleveland Browns' 21-15 loss to the New York Giants on Sunday once again highlighted ongoing concerns about head coach Kevin Stefanski’s play-calling and inability to adapt during games. Despite a promising start, with Deshaun Watson connecting on a 24-yard touchdown pass to Amari Cooper on the first play from scrimmage, the Browns' offensive scheme quickly faltered.

Photos Provided To Cleveland 13 By Tim Phillis

Stefanski’s play-calling has become a source of frustration for fans and analysts alike. After the opening drive, the offense seemed predictable and rigid. Watson was forced to drop back repeatedly behind a struggling offensive line that allowed him to be sacked eight times—a career-high. Injuries to the line have certainly played a role, but questions remain as to why Stefanski continues to rely so heavily on the passing game when protection is clearly an issue. Watson finished 21 of 37 for 196 yards and two touchdowns, but with just 5.3 yards per attempt, the offense failed to generate consistent momentum.

The decision to abandon the run game, especially in short-yardage situations, is a recurring problem. The Browns have a strong running back corps, but once again, Stefanski turned to the air early and often, even as the offensive line struggled to hold up. This lack of adjustment raises concerns about the coach’s ability to adapt in real-time—a critical trait in the NFL.

On defense, Jim Schwartz’s unit showed flashes of potential but was ultimately undone by costly mistakes. Giants rookie wide receiver Malik Nabers repeatedly exposed Browns cornerback Martin Emerson, catching eight passes for 78 yards and scoring two touchdowns. Giants quarterback Daniel Jones had a productive day, completing 24 of 34 passes for 236 yards and two touchdowns.

Amari Cooper, one of the few bright spots, caught seven passes for 86 yards and two touchdowns, showing improvement from his performance the previous week. However, his contributions weren’t enough to overcome the broader issues plaguing the offense.

The absence of veteran offensive line coach Bill Callahan continues to have a noticeable impact on the Browns' protection schemes. Without his leadership, the offensive line has been unable to provide Watson with the time he needs in the pocket. Ken Dorsey, the newly hired offensive coordinator from the Buffalo Bills, was expected to inject creativity into the Browns' attack, but thus far, the team’s offense appears largely unchanged.

As the Browns move forward, the pressure on Stefanski to make in-game adjustments will only intensify. Scripting a strong first drive is not enough to win in the NFL, especially when defenses quickly adjust. The Browns’ inability to make necessary offensive changes mid-game is costing them, and it’s unclear how long the team can continue without addressing these flaws.